May it please your Lordship,
Fahri Azzat for the Petitioner, Hoe Sue Lu.
My distinguished learned friends for the Bar, the Kuala Lumpur Bar Committee and the Attorney General’s Chambers were introduced earlier.
My Lord, my speech this morning will take about six minutes. There are 3 parts to my speech. The first is an introduction of the Petitioner and how she came to the law. The second is why she is a fit and proper person. And I will finish off my speech with a round of thanks.
The first part.
My Lord, in my experience, there are only 2 kinds of people that end up in law. Those that knew soon after birth they were destined for law. And those that did not have a clue what to do with themselves. The latter often possess a strong aversion to maths and blood, thus ruling them out for the other great Asian employments – Accountancy, Engineering and Medicine. The Petitioner, who hails from Petaling Jaya, like many before her, applied the Asian Employment calculation and unsurprisingly ended up in the law. “I decided to do law because I did not know what other subjects I could take since I did not like maths and science. Coming from an Asian background, law seems to be a convenient choice.”
Some of us hear the call of law early, some later. What is important is to hear it. So, it was with the Petitioner. Her passion for law was stirred after she completed her Bachelor of Laws in June 2016 and Certificate of Legal Practice at Brickfields Asia College in August 2017.
That passion was sparked, as it commonly is, by injustice. “What really makes me want to be a lawyer is my 4 months internship with SUARAM where I was exposed to human rights violations such as unlawful detention and detention without trial under SOSMA and POCA. It was there that it really strikes me that there is so much injustice and unfairness where people are so powerless and vulnerable to authorities.” Were it not for her experience with injustice, she would not have come to the law filled with drive. Here is a thought – if we have more justice in this world, fewer lawyers there will be!
The second part.
There are 3 reasons why I submit the Petitioner is a fit and proper person to be called to the Bar, aside from her passion for justice and the law.
The first is her adaptability. Even though the Petitioner had ideas of delving into intellectual property during her pupillage, she ended up at Messrs AmerBon, under the tutelage of Encik Amer Hamzah. As one would expect under the great criminal lawyer, she did a whole lot of criminal law instead and has cultivated a great passion for it too.
When she spoke about the case she was most deeply involved in, the murder of naval officer Zulfarhan Osman Zulkarnain, that died due to torture by his fellow cadet officers, it was as if she was telling me about her loved one. She had her share of civil cases during pupillage as well – claims for breach of trust and preparing opinions about inter-faith marriages. I think it is her ability with language that shows the range of her adaptability. She was educated in Mandarin; speaks English and Cantonese to her mother, Hakka to her father and is adept at Bahasa Malaysia as well.
The second is her resolution. Even though the Petitioner chose the law out of convenience, she resolved to know it and understand it better. Before she started her law degree she worked as an assistant secretary with a law firm for 3 months between June to August 2013 for the specific purpose of understanding the legal industry prior to the law degree. She did a 2-month internship at another law firm after completing her Bachelor of Laws and then her 4-month stint at SUARAM after completing her CLP. Her reason for joining SUARAM instead of a law firm for her last internship was because she wanted something related but not directly in the law before she started her pupillage.
This I submit is a mark of maturity, resolve and dedication – to commit to her decision after she has decided upon it. When I compare the Petitioner’s development with my own, I confess I fall far short. The only thing I recall trying to find out prior to my pupillage was where the bar was, and it wasn’t the Bar Council I was looking for.
The third and final reason is her orientation toward the law. The Petitioner has I believe the right starting point for her ideas about the law and what our role as lawyers is in society. She wrote, I believe that the law as a social contract should benefit the people. Fundamentally, the rule of law is to provide peace and order in society. Simultaneously, it should also protect fundamental human rights. For example, to have order in society, there are a list of offences and punishments respectively, but at the same time the accused is given the right to trial. The law is there to provide guidance and mechanism to maintain societal order.’
If that is the Petitioner’s starting point for law, then she can only deepen and improve that view of the law in the time to come.
The phrase the Petitioner resonates with is per aspera as astra. This means through hardship you will reach the stars. I have no doubt that the Petitioner will be on her way to the stars in the years to come especially when she has two of the Bar’s leading lights in her firmament in her Master, Encik Amer Hamzah, and the inimitable Mr Edmund Bon. I have no doubt they will inflict much hardship on the Petitioner too. The Petitioner has been retained and will continue under their tutelage. I would like to take this opportunity to congratulate her.
The third part.
The Petitioner would like to thank her father, Mr Hoe Kai Yong, and mother Madam Chow Mee Mooi, as well as her younger brother, Hoe Yik Ming and younger sister, Hoe Shuang Lu, for their unwavering support, love, and trust. The Petitioner would also like to thank all those in Messrs AmerBon Advocates who have helped, taught and were an inspiration to her.
I submit the cause papers are in order and my learned friends do not have any objection to the petition.
I pray that the Petitioner, Ho Sue Lu be admitted and enrolled as an advocate and solicitor in the High Court of Malaya.
Called on 14.11.2018.